Investors Like Less Spending

Growth isn’t always good. The Shale Revolution led to enormous growth in U.S. oil and gas output, but abundance pressured prices and, for investors in U.S. exploration and production, it’s been a bust. Midstream energy infrastructure joined in the race for growth projects – but not every investment was accretive. Some, like Plains All American (PAGP), have seen their stock price lose 90% of its value since 2014. It’s the result of serial bad capital allocation decisions. The drop in Permian crude output caused by Covid will leave PAGP with excess pipeline capacity in the region.

Energy investors have become so wary of growth capital expenditures that they now cheer when a company reduces future spending. Enterprise Products Partners (EPD) has managed their business better than most over the past few years. Their investment in new infrastructure plus acquisitions peaked in 2014, and had already resumed its downward trend last year before the pandemic caused an industry-wide reassessment.

EPD last week canceled their planned Midland to Echo 4 (M2E4) pipeline carrying crude from the Permian to storage facilities on the Gulf of Mexico. Although much of the 450,000 barrels per day of capacity was already committed, EPD was able to get its customers to agree to extend the term of their agreements while reducing near term volume commitments. The crude oil originally intended for M2E4 will now move on other parts of EPD’s pipeline network.

Excess pipeline capacity out of west Texas is the most visible consequence of Covid on U.S. oil output. EPD’s move helps them but doesn’t solve the problem for other pipeline operators. “The Permian will still be significantly overbuilt” warned Ethan Bellamy, managing director of midstream strategy at East Daley Capital Advisors.

On Wednesday morning when the news was announced, EPD’s stock opened strongly and outperformed the American Energy Independence Index (AEITR) by 2% on the day. EPD estimates its growth capex will be $800MM lower over the next couple of years as a result, continuing the trend of recent years.

Lower growth spending means more free cash flow. CEO Jim Teague commented that, “The capital savings from the cancellation of M2E4 will accelerate Enterprise toward being discretionary free cash flow positive, which would give us the flexibility to reduce debt and return additional capital to our partners, including through buybacks.”

This is welcome news, and represents the new normal in the pipeline business.

We expect free cash flow for the industry to more than double this year. From our calls with investors, there’s substantial interest in today’s attractive yields, especially following 2Q earnings. EPD stands out with a distribution yield 3X their 30 year debt. As the industry continues to generate more cash, equity buyers will start to appreciate the long term stability of the best run businesses, as bond buyers already do.

We are invested in all the components of the American Energy Independence Index via the ETF that seeks to track its performance. We are also invested in PAGP and EPD via the SMAs and mutual fund we manage.


Print Friendly, PDF & Email
2 replies
  1. Marty
    Marty says:

    I enjoy your articles and read them every week. I added to both my EPD and PAGP holdings on Friday. Morningstar reaffirmed their Fair Value for EPD last week at 25.50.

    Comments694 | Following
    I added to my large EPD position today near 17. Morningstar just updated their report on EPD, and reaffirmed their Fair Value of 25.50 for it.
    Fair Value and Profit Drivers | by Stephen Ellis Updated Sep 09, 2020
    After updating our model to the Midland-to-ECHO 4 cancelation, we retain our $25.50 fair value estimate. Our fair value estimate implies a 2020 EBITDA multiple of 10.6 times, a 2021 enterprise value/EBITDA multiple of 10.8 times, and a 2020 distribution yield of 7%.
    We expect the main driver for Enterprise will be its NGL segment, as the demand pull from the Gulf Coast and international markets lets Enterprise take advantage of the export opportunities and lucrative differentials via its comprehensive asset base. We also expect increased demand for ethane will benefit Enterprise as well. However, the diversity of Enterprise’s asset base, its ability to take advantage of just about any profitable opportunity that appears in U.S. midstream, and its largely fee-based earnings stream all support healthy single-digit growth prospects over the next few years. We expect EBITDA to increase about 1% annually over the next five years and distributions about 1-2% annually on average over the same time frame.

  2. Ken
    Ken says:

    The variable I think the majority of investors struggle with oil/gas midstream/producers is the ongoing transition to renewables. What’s your intuition on the profitable Lifespan of pipeline stocks in general. ie Is it X years and than a rapid decline in share price to zero? Is it 10,15,25?


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.